Managers Trim BHP After Copper's Record as the November Reports Land
PM Capital, Paradice, Endeavor and Investors Mutual all reduced BHP, while Perpetual cut its underweight and Janus Henderson and Antares made the case for a copper re-rating.
20 Nov 2026 · 6 min read

In short
PM Capital, Paradice Investment Management, Endeavor Asset Management and Investors Mutual all reported reducing BHP in October and November 2026, with Endeavor trimming it from 8% to 7% of one portfolio.
The common thread is valuation after copper hit a record in September: PM Capital said much of the long-term optimism on copper is now reflected in valuations, and Paradice cut Resources to a meaningful underweight.
Not every manager is selling: Perpetual reduced its underweight after the October fall, and Janus Henderson and Antares Capital argued in November that BHP's copper growth could support a higher valuation.
Managers bank gains as the November reports land
The monthly and quarterly reports arriving in November show a cluster of fund managers taking money off the table in BHP. PM Capital, in a quarterly report published in November 2026, said it reduced the fund's positioning across the copper sector, selling down both BHP and Capstone Copper near their quarter highs after copper prices hit an all-time high in September. The manager made clear this was not a change of heart on the metal: “While we retain a favourable long-term view on copper fundamentals, we believe much of that optimism is now reflected in current valuations.”
While we retain a favourable long-term view on copper fundamentals, we believe much of that optimism is now reflected in current valuations.
— PM Capital, Quarterly Report, November 2026
The October 2026 monthly reports tell a similar story. Paradice Investment Management said it reduced positions in PLS, Lynas and BHP “as commodity-price momentum slowed,” as part of narrowly reducing portfolio beta because the rapid rise in interest rates increased the risk of a pullback. Paradice went further on the sector as a whole: “We have reduced Resources to a meaningful underweight after strong commodity and share-price performance pushed several stocks beyond our valuation targets.”
Endeavor Asset Management, whose August report showed BHP as the largest holding in its portfolios at 8.7% and 8.9%, reported in October that “BHP was trimmed from 8% to 7%” in one portfolio. Endeavor gave no specific reason, but the same month it opened positions in Austal, Alcoa and CAR Group and exited CSL and Centuria Capital. This article follows an earlier look at how managers split over AI demand versus the tariff trade in copper; the newer reports show more managers acting on price.
Investors Mutual pares back a large position
Investors Mutual Limited explained its own trimming in an October 2026 article. A year earlier the share price was 50% lower and the manager held a 10% position, which it has since pared back. Investors Mutual still described BHP as the best of the major miners because of its tier-one assets and its diversification across coal, copper and iron ore, but it set out two reasons for owning less. “Iron ore supply-demand dynamics aren't that favourable, particularly with Simandou coming on,” the manager said, adding: “Copper is favourable, but we see BHP as being priced for that today.”
Investors Mutual has also been using the share price to earn income. In its October 2026 monthly report it said the fund wrote options on core holdings, including BHP, “at levels consistent with our valuations.” Ten Cap had moved earlier. Its September 2026 monthly report said it trimmed BHP into strength after a 10% gain in the month, adding that iron ore had held up better than expected but that it saw limited further upside and preferred to hold resource exposure “through gold and copper where the earnings leverage is greater.”
The valuation question behind the selling
Seneca Financial Solutions, speaking in a November 2026 article, put the valuation case plainly. Seneca holds BHP because, as a benchmarked active manager, it almost always has to, but it said it is materially underweight. “At seventeen times, BHP’s not cheap by anyone’s metrics,” Seneca said, describing that multiple as one standard deviation above average. Its larger concern is iron ore, which it said “looks like it’s about to go through a significantly weak period” as new supply arrives from Africa. Seneca cautioned against assuming those projects ramp up smoothly, but still said “there’s enough cause for concern that prices stay below average – or definitely below recent prices – for a year or two from here.”
At seventeen times, BHP’s not cheap by anyone’s metrics.
— Seneca Financial Solutions, Article, November 2026
Pendal Group, which excludes BHP from its investable universe because of its coal exposure, noted in its October 2026 monthly report that its underweight helped as the stock fell 5.4% with the mining sector. Pendal described a soft quarterly production report on lower copper volumes, though “the result was largely as expected” and guidance was unchanged.
Perpetual moves the other way
One of the more telling moves in October came from a manager that remains underweight. Perpetual Asset Management said in its October 2026 monthly report that its underweight in BHP was a top contributor for the second month running. Perpetual explained that BHP traded at 5 to 6 times EV/EBITDA for several years before breaking out at the start of 2026 and peaking at about 8.5 times in late August, while its dividend yield fell to 3%, the lowest in more than 10 years. It attributed that re-rating mainly to the market's focus on copper.
Perpetual still holds less than the index, but it bought some back after the fall. “This underweight has been reduced given recent share price weakness,” the manager said, recorded in the database as an increase.
The case for a copper re-rating
Two managers used November articles to argue that the copper story has further to run. Janus Henderson Investors, which continues to hold BHP, said copper became the company's biggest contributor to earnings in the last financial year and that its project pipeline could support an even higher valuation. “Copper stocks tend to trade at much higher multiples than diversified miners,” Janus Henderson said. “You can see that with BHP, which is pivoting to a growth profile. The market’s starting to see that.” The manager also pointed to frequent flooding and other operational setbacks that constrain copper supply.
Antares Capital, also writing in November, built its argument on three businesses. On copper, it pointed to Escondida, Copper South Australia and the Vicuña project, which it said will come online towards the end of this decade, and added: “The copper story is not just around AI and demand. It’s also a supply issue.” On iron ore, Antares said BHP sits at the bottom of the cost curve and that supply is already leaving the market from high-cost Chinese and Brazilian producers. On potash, it said the Jansen project is not contributing to earnings today but will start to ramp up in 12 to 18 months. “We think over time that will lead to a rerating of BHP because it’s more diversified,” Antares said.
We think over time that will lead to a rerating of BHP because it’s more diversified.
— Antares Capital, Article, November 2026
Holders hedge rather than sell
Several managers that kept BHP in October reported protecting the position rather than reducing it. Blackwattle Investment Partners said in its October 2026 monthly report that BHP was the largest detractor in its Equity Income Quality Fund as iron ore and copper prices weakened, but that “BHP remains a core holding” and the position is well covered with call options that generated significant premium income during the month. Milford Asset Management said BHP fell 5.4% as the market questioned the sustainability of the AI rollout and, by extension, copper demand, and that “The Fund was partially protected from this decline through some put options owned on BHP and Rio Tinto for just this risk.”
Clime Investment Management, which also holds, described a mixed quarter in which strong iron ore performance was offset by weaker copper production after operational disruptions and lower grades. “The near-term production challenges warrant attention, while BHP’s diversified operations and copper exposure continue to support the longer-term investment case,” Clime said in its October 2026 monthly report.
What managers are watching next
The managers trimming BHP are not disputing copper's long-term demand. PM Capital, Investors Mutual and Paradice each framed their moves around how much of that outlook is already in the share price. The next tests they point to are the iron ore price as new African supply arrives, copper volumes after the soft September quarter, and the ramp-up of Jansen. For now the November reports show more managers taking profits than adding, with Perpetual's partial buyback the main exception.
Questions
Which fund managers reduced BHP in October and November 2026?
PM Capital, Paradice Investment Management, Endeavor Asset Management and Investors Mutual Limited all reported reducing BHP, with Endeavor trimming it from 8% to 7% of one portfolio and Investors Mutual paring back a position that had been 10% a year earlier.
Why did PM Capital sell BHP shares after copper's record high?
PM Capital said it reduced its copper sector exposure, selling BHP and Capstone Copper near their quarter highs after copper hit an all-time high in September 2026, because it believes much of the optimism about copper is now reflected in current valuations.
Which managers argued BHP could re-rate higher in November 2026?
Janus Henderson Investors said BHP is pivoting to a growth profile and that copper stocks trade at higher multiples than diversified miners, while Antares Capital said copper supply constraints, low-cost iron ore and the Jansen potash project could lead to a re-rating over time.
50 managers, 166 comments, with each manager's latest recorded position.
See BHP