Pengana Cuts Regis From a Top Five Holding and Recycles Into Netwealth, Guzman y Gomez and FDC
In an October 2026 webinar and its September monthly report, Pengana Capital Group called its aged care call an error, sold Sigma for being too big and explained why it prefers Netwealth to HUB24.
17 Nov 2026 · 5 min read

In short
Pengana Capital Group cut Regis Healthcare from a top five holding to a very small weight after the federal government cut aged care funding, saying it was probably its error to assume the government would follow the logic.
Pengana exited Sigma Healthcare because at about $40 billion it had become too large and widely analysed, and exited Amcor and Tyro, while opening positions in Guzman y Gomez, Zip and FDC Consolidated.
In wealth platforms, Pengana moved its preference from HUB24 to Netwealth on valuation while keeping very large weightings in both, and said it is highly excited about Generation Development.
An unusually candid account of a mistake
Few fund managers describe their own errors as plainly as Pengana Capital Group did in an October 2026 webinar. Discussing Regis Healthcare, the aged care operator, Pengana said its thesis had rested on a shortage of new beds that the government would act to close. “The thinking was that the government would stimulate the market to close this supply-demand gap, but strangely they did the complete reverse and cut funding, which drove the recent share price fall,” the manager said. “It's probably our error assuming the government would follow the logic.”
The consequence was a large change in position size. “Regis was a top five holding of ours; we now have a very small weight because of our changed thinking around funding in the sector, and we will recycle that money into companies where we have far greater relative confidence in prospects,” Pengana said.
It's probably our error assuming the government would follow the logic.
— Pengana Capital Group, Webinar, October 2026
The cut began a month earlier. In its September 2026 monthly report, Pengana said Regis fell 29% after “a disappointing federal funding decision, which makes it difficult for the company to offset wage inflation in their aged care facilities,” and that it had “significantly reduced our holding to reflect this risk.”
Selling Sigma for being too big
The Sigma Healthcare exit had nothing to do with the business. “Selling out of Sigma is plain and simple: it got too large,” Pengana said in the webinar. “It's a $40 billion company, so there's a lot of prying eyes looking at that company. We prefer to put that money into something with less analytical coverage where we can find a competitive advantage in terms of mispricing.”
That preference for less-followed companies runs through Pengana's commentary. It described Redox, a chemical wholesaler, as “a stock not well owned, not in any index,” followed by only a couple of brokers, which it believes is “part of the reason for the mispricing.”
Pengana also sold Amcor in September, writing that “the good news on currency and merger synergies has played out, while input cost pressures and consumer weakness remain as risks.” It exited Tyro Payments, a very small position, “after some regulatory issues in the Singapore market.”
Where the money is going
The new positions are mostly companies Pengana believes the market has marked down. Guzman y Gomez was one it passed on at listing, when it said it was “not at all excited” about the price. “Things have changed a lot,” Pengana said in October, pointing to the company's renewed focus on Australia, and it took “an initial, albeit a small, position” after the shares fell.
FDC Consolidated, a recent IPO, drew some of the strongest language in the webinar. Pengana described it as “very conservatively run,” listing with 25% of its market value in cash and with founders still owning half the business. “On a P/E of 10 times it is exceptionally cheap, in our view, given the track record and certainty with management,” the manager said.
Zip Co was the largest addition in September, “initiated after a 20% fall in the share price.” Pengana then wrote that “operating leverage continues to pick up materially, bad debts are under control.” By October, after Zip fell on its quarterly update, Pengana explained why it keeps the position small. “Consumer finance businesses always have incredible inherent risk, and we would always keep the weight low because of that, almost regardless of the upside,” it said, adding that it kept Zip at about half of 1% of the fund.
Consumer finance businesses always have incredible inherent risk, and we would always keep the weight low because of that, almost regardless of the upside.
— Pengana Capital Group, Webinar, October 2026
Netwealth over HUB24, on price alone
Wealth platforms are among Pengana's largest bets, and the September sell-off hurt. In its September monthly report, Pengana said Netwealth fell 21%, HUB24 16% and Generation Development 13% as higher bond rates dragged down valuations. “We see remarkable growth ahead for these companies, and are reminded of prior periods when the market was too heavily focused on short-term trends, which created very attractive buying opportunities,” it wrote.
In October, Pengana shifted the balance between the two largest platforms. “We've moved our preference from Hub24 to Netwealth, while still having a very large weighting in the two of those stocks,” it said, describing it as “simply a valuation discussion.” Pengana cited a price to earnings ratio of 23 times for Netwealth against 28 times for HUB24, and noted that “Netwealth listed 10 years ago on EBITDA margins of 50% and the EBITDA margins today are still 50%, because they keep investing their scale advantage into building out their competitive position.”
HUB24 remains a long-term success for the fund. “When we bought Hub24 it had 1% of the platform market; it now has 10% and we expect that to grow to 20% over time,” Pengana said, noting the stock is up 20 times since it bought it 10 years ago.
When we bought Hub24 it had 1% of the platform market; it now has 10% and we expect that to grow to 20% over time.
— Pengana Capital Group, Webinar, October 2026
On Generation Development, Pengana said it trimmed slightly about five months ago because of higher compliance costs across the sector after First Guardian and Shield, and acknowledged the company had “probably kicked a couple of own goals” by over-promising on its Evidentia acquisition. Despite that, Pengana said “we're highly excited by this stock,” with earnings “expected to grow 25% plus” on a market multiple, and called it a top five holding.
Trimming into strength elsewhere
Pengana also took profits in two strong performers in September. It trimmed Ampol into strength after a 9% rise, saying its thesis rests on “the more lasting impacts on global refining supply” rather than the oil price. It trimmed Wagners, which it said had risen more than 400% over two years on concrete demand in south-east Queensland and expected pre-Olympics spending in Brisbane. At the same time it kept building positions in Flight Centre and Seek “with discipline.”
What Pengana is watching
Pengana's recent commentary describes a manager pulling capital from a policy-dependent thesis and from a company that had become too widely followed, and moving it into smaller or out-of-favour names it believes are mispriced. The tests it has laid out are whether platform flows recover from what it calls a transitory budget-related lull, whether FDC's record continues as a listed company, and whether Zip's bad debts stay under control.
Questions
Why did Pengana Capital Group reduce Regis Healthcare?
Pengana Capital Group cut Regis Healthcare from a top five holding to a very small weight in 2026 after the federal government cut aged care funding instead of stimulating new bed supply, which Pengana said was probably its error in assuming the government would follow the logic.
Why did Pengana sell Sigma Healthcare?
Pengana Capital Group said in October 2026 that it sold Sigma Healthcare because the company had grown to about $40 billion in value and attracted wide analyst coverage, and it prefers less-followed companies where it can find mispricing.
Does Pengana prefer Netwealth or HUB24?
Pengana Capital Group moved its preference from HUB24 to Netwealth in October 2026 on valuation, citing price to earnings ratios of 23 times for Netwealth and 28 times for HUB24, while keeping very large weightings in both.
18 managers, 49 comments, with each manager's latest recorded position.
See REG