Coles Guides to Flat Supermarket Earnings as Managers Question the Defensive Trade
Coles' first-quarter slowdown and flat EBIT guidance have split fund managers. Some see supply chain leverage and food inflation ahead; others say supermarkets have done their job and are taking profits.
15 Nov 2026 · 5 min read

In short
Pendal Group said Coles' supermarket sales growth slowed to about 3% by October and that its guidance for flat first-half supermarket EBIT was 6% below consensus, implying an earnings downgrade of about 8%.
Several managers have reduced supermarket holdings: Airlie exited Coles for valuation reasons, Lazard sold Woolworths after its recovery, and Ten Cap and Allan Gray trimmed Woolworths.
Others still back the sector: Antares Capital points to Coles' automated supply chain delivering fixed-cost leverage, and Wilson Asset Management says El Niño could lift food inflation and help both supermarkets' sales.
Coles' guidance changes the conversation
The supermarkets were the market's safe harbour for much of 2026. In November, Coles gave fund managers a reason to look harder at that assumption. Pendal Group, in its November 2026 newsletter, said Coles' supermarket sales growth slowed from 3.7% in July and August to 3.4% in September “and then further into October (but remained at least ~3%).”
Pendal said slowing sales, higher fuel costs and price investment led Coles to guide to flat supermarket EBIT for the first half of FY27, “which was 6% below consensus and implied an ~8% NPAT downgrade which is likely to be extrapolated by consensus.” Pendal also said prior consensus for 4.6% first-half sales growth “appears to be too high,” even though Coles laps an easier comparable period in November and December.
Woolworths, by contrast, kept growing faster. Pendal said Woolworths' Australian Food sales rose 6.9% in the first quarter, easing to about 6% in September and October but still ahead of Coles. Pendal said tough November and December comparisons are “the next test,” with about 4% growth needed to meet prior consensus.
The case that the defensive trade has run its course
Several managers had already started reducing supermarket exposure before the update. Ten Cap, in its September 2026 monthly report, said it reduced Woolworths because “supermarkets have done their job as a defensive holding, with Staples up 15% over the year and trading near the top of their valuation range.” Ten Cap said it is rotating that capital “into consumer names with better valuation support.”
Supermarkets have done their job as a defensive holding, with Staples up 15% over the year and trading near the top of their valuation range.
— Ten Cap, Monthly Report, September 2026
Airlie Funds Management exited Coles in the September quarter, saying simply: “We also exited Coles for valuation reasons.” Lazard Asset Management said in an October 2026 article that it had bought Woolworths as one of several “fallen angels” that had fallen sharply from high multiples, and that “we have already sold Woolworths after the share price recovery.”
Allan Gray trimmed Woolworths too, explaining in an October 2026 presentation that the share price “has gone up quite significantly, and there's a lot now baked into its share price in terms of growth,” while profits are below historical averages and New Zealand and Big W are struggling. Allan Gray was careful to separate the business from the stock: “We think it's very well run, notwithstanding what you might read in the press. And it's a great company, but not all great companies are companies one needs to own necessarily.”
Seneca Financial Solutions made the sharpest argument against Coles in a November 2026 article. Seneca said investors do not own Coles for a 3.62% dividend yield, which it said is below the risk-free rate, or for 2% profit growth, and that the stock trades on 24 times earnings, “a 37% premium to the rest of the market.” Seneca said it saw little point in owning Coles outside a pairs trade against Woolworths.
The case for Coles: a supply chain that should start paying back
Antares Capital argued the opposite in the same week. Antares described Coles as very defensive at a time when “we’re all eating at home more,” and pointed to years of spending on automation. “Coles is in a unique position where they’ve spent billions of dollars, and I think five years, building their supply chain to the point where it’s now starting to deliver that fixed-cost leverage,” Antares said. It expects sales growth for both supermarkets to remain strong, with Coles benefiting “on a relatively fixed cost base.”
Coles is in a unique position where they’ve spent billions of dollars, and I think five years, building their supply chain to the point where it’s now starting to deliver that fixed-cost leverage.
— Antares Capital, Article, November 2026
Wilson Asset Management, which holds both Coles and Woolworths, offered a different reason for optimism in an October 2026 presentation. Wilson said El Niño “can disrupt harvest around the world and global stock piles are really running thin,” which “could really drive food inflation,” generally positive for supermarket sales. Wilson acknowledged that neither stock is cheap on historical measures, but said that “when the companies are executing really well and growing earnings, especially against a favorable industry backdrop, valuations tend to stay higher for longer.”
Contact Asset Management continues to hold both in BKI, saying in its September 2026 quarterly report that Coles delivered another solid result with operating leverage coming through, and that Woolworths “has clearly regained market leadership in the space.” PM Capital increased its holding of Coles bonds in its Enhanced Yield Fund at yields of about 6% to 6.5%, describing Coles as a “dominant Australian supermarket giant” among companies “that we believe can sustain their earnings through a more strained economic environment.”
Liquor and independents: the weaker corners
Managers are more cautious about the parts of food and liquor retailing outside the two big supermarkets. Allan Gray, which holds Endeavour Group, said in its September 2026 quarterly report that Coles' liquor retail margins, including lease costs, had fallen from around 4% historically to about 1%, which “would likely mean a paltry return on invested capital.” It also noted that Metcash reported flat liquor sales to independent retailers.
On Metcash itself, Allan Gray said in October that independent grocers such as IGA tend to have a higher cost base, and “as the consumer tightens their belts,” shoppers may move to Woolworths, Coles and Aldi. Pendal said in October that Metcash appeared likely to pull back on ambitions to increase retail exposure in food, “an incremental positive for the stock.”
Endeavour remains a test of patience. Allan Gray said its total return on the stock over the year to 23 September was -15%, and an October 2026 article quoted its quarterly update: “at best, we were too early with our initial Endeavour investment,” and “this is no different to being wrong.” It is staying, citing the chief executive's on-market purchase of $1 million of shares and its confidence that the liquor sector will recover. Ellerston Capital bought back into Endeavour in October at “much lower prices and more attractive valuation levels.” Pendal, however, said in November that Endeavour's liquor sales growth slowed from 4.6% to 1.4% across the first quarter, with further gross margin declines expected in the first half.
What managers are watching
The next markers are the November and December trading periods. Pendal says Woolworths needs about 4% growth to meet expectations and that Coles' first-half consensus looks too high. Antares is watching for the fixed-cost leverage from Coles' automated distribution centres to show up in profit, and Wilson for food inflation to lift sales. For the managers who have sold, the question is whether supermarkets trading near the top of their valuation range can keep growing into those prices.
Questions
Why did Coles shares fall in November 2026?
Pendal Group said Coles' supermarket sales growth slowed to about 3% by October 2026 and that, because of slowing sales, higher fuel costs and price investment, Coles guided to flat first-half supermarket EBIT, 6% below consensus and implying an earnings downgrade of about 8%.
Which fund managers have sold supermarket shares in 2026?
Airlie Funds Management exited Coles for valuation reasons in the September 2026 quarter, Lazard Asset Management sold Woolworths after its share price recovery, and Ten Cap and Allan Gray trimmed Woolworths, with Ten Cap saying supermarkets had done their job as a defensive holding.
What do fund managers see as the positive case for Coles?
Antares Capital said in November 2026 that Coles' years of supply chain investment are starting to deliver fixed-cost leverage that should support profit growth, and Wilson Asset Management said El Niño could drive food inflation that lifts sales at both Coles and Woolworths.
23 managers, 38 comments, with each manager's latest recorded position.
See COL