Bunnings Slows to 1 to 2% Growth and Managers Split Over the Price of Wesfarmers
Paradice exited and Milford trimmed as Bunnings sales growth faded at the AGM, while Ten Cap and Perennial bought after the shares fell from 34 to 26 times earnings.
18 Nov 2026 · 4 min read

In short
Wesfarmers told its AGM that Bunnings sales growth had moderated, with recent weeks the weakest; Pendal Group estimated October growth at 1 to 2%, below consensus of 3.6% for the first half.
Milford Asset Management trimmed Wesfarmers in October and Paradice Investment Management exited in the September quarter, both citing a softening consumer and slower housing turnover.
Ten Cap and Perennial Partners bought in September after the shares derated from 34 to 26 times earnings, arguing Bunnings and Kmart are high-quality businesses at a more attractive price.
Bunnings blinks at the AGM
The debate over Wesfarmers has moved from what the business is worth in theory to what Bunnings is doing right now. In a November 2026 newsletter, Pendal Group reported that the conglomerate used its AGM update to say Bunnings year-to-date sales growth “has moderated since 2H26, with recent weeks the weakest.” Lower sales in seasonal categories and the commercial segment were flagged as the key negative.
Pendal put numbers on the slowdown. Growth, it said, “moderated from >4% in Jul/Aug to likely 1-2% in October which is below consensus at 3.6% for 1H27.” Kmart sales growth was broadly in line with the second half of FY26 at about 2.2%, slightly below first-half consensus. Pendal noted consensus earnings per share forecasts fell 2% for each of FY27 to FY29, and the shares fell 4.5%.
Milford Asset Management had moved before the update. In its October 2026 monthly report, Milford said consumer spending continued to soften through AGM season and that it reduced its Wesfarmers position “following a share price bounce ahead of what we expected to be a weak read on the consumer.”
A great business at a full price
The sellers rarely question the quality of the business. Their argument is about price. Antares Capital, in a November 2026 article, called Wesfarmers “a great conglomerate” with a very good business and governance, but added that “a great business is not always a good investment, and now is one of those times.” Antares said Bunnings and Kmart are growing about 5% a year, that “for that you’re paying 30 times,” and that a housing downturn is coming.
A great business is not always a good investment, and now is one of those times.
— Antares Capital, Article, November 2026
Seneca Financial Solutions, in the same November article, made a similar case from the shopper's side. Seneca noted that Wesfarmers is on 28 to 30 times earnings and that 43% of earnings come from Bunnings, at a time of a cost-of-living crisis. “You’re not going to be out there spending squillions on renovating your house or doing major spending at Bunnings,” Seneca said. It described Kmart's discretionary categories as “increasingly competitive with Temu, Amazon and almost every other internet retailer.” Seneca added that it still owns retailers it sees as having a proven store rollout, naming Universal Store and Lovisa, but that at almost double their multiple it does not see Wesfarmers as the better use of capital.
Paradice Investment Management exited in the September 2026 quarter. Its quarterly report said Wesfarmers was sold “as the higher rate outlook and slower housing turnover may dampen consumer spending.” Yarra Capital Management, which holds an underweight position, said in its September quarterly that Bunnings and Kmart have “outsized exposure to housing turnover and interest rates,” and that with the stock on 28 times FY27 earnings against a 10-year average of 23.4 times and a 3.1% dividend yield, “expectations remain relatively high for the stock.”
Solaris Investment Management and Equity Trustees Asset Management are also underweight. Solaris said in its September quarterly that softer growth at Bunnings, mixed early FY27 trading and elevated capital expenditure tempered expectations, even though Bunnings and Kmart “remain high-quality, high-return businesses, and lithium offers optionality.” Equity Trustees, which holds no Wesfarmers, said the FY26 result showed the retail businesses “are growing slower than retail sales in general” and that “there has not been the margin of safety to invest.”
The buyers who waited for the derating
On the other side are managers that used the September fall to buy. Ten Cap said in its September 2026 monthly report that it bought back into Wesfarmers after the shares fell 15% over the quarter and derated “from 34 times to 26 times.” Ten Cap described Bunnings and Kmart as “the domestic consumer names we are comfortable owning, given their scale and value positioning,”. It added: “Wesfarmers, which derated from 34 times to 26 times, will grow sales through category additions, while margins expand through direct procurement.” Ten Cap also noted that a softer CPI print lowered the risk of a November rate rise.
Wesfarmers, which derated from 34 times to 26 times, will grow sales through category additions, while margins expand through direct procurement.
— Ten Cap, Monthly Report, September 2026
Ten Cap's own reporting shows how finely balanced the call is. In another of its portfolios in the same month, it trimmed Wesfarmers, saying Bunnings “remains an exceptional franchise, but the tax change and the policy induced slowdown in housing and consumer spending are direct headwinds, and the multiple leaves no room for disappointment.”
Perennial Partners moved overweight in September. Its monthly report said Wesfarmers “is obviously a high-quality business, and following its recent sell-off, it was presenting a more attractive valuation.” Perennial funded the addition by trimming and exiting other holdings. Contact Asset Management, which holds Wesfarmers in BKI, said in its September quarterly that the group “again demonstrated the benefits of owning high-quality businesses with strong market positions,” and that its balance sheet gives it room to pursue growth and return capital.
What managers are watching
The AGM update has handed the sellers their first evidence: Bunnings growth of 1 to 2% in October against a 3.6% consensus, as Pendal reported. The buyers' case depends on Bunnings and Kmart holding their share through a soft patch, and on the lower multiple Ten Cap and Perennial bought at. The next readings on Bunnings trading through the rest of the first half, housing turnover and interest rates are the points both groups have named.
Questions
Why did Wesfarmers shares fall after its 2026 AGM?
Wesfarmers said at its AGM that Bunnings sales growth had moderated, with recent weeks the weakest; Pendal Group estimated growth slowed from above 4% in July and August to 1 to 2% in October, below consensus of 3.6%, and the shares fell 4.5%.
Which fund managers sold or reduced Wesfarmers in late 2026?
Paradice Investment Management exited Wesfarmers in the September 2026 quarter, citing the higher rate outlook and slower housing turnover, and Milford Asset Management reduced its position in October 2026 ahead of what it expected to be a weak read on the consumer.
Which fund managers bought Wesfarmers in 2026, and why?
Ten Cap bought back into Wesfarmers in September 2026 after the shares derated from 34 to 26 times earnings, and Perennial Partners moved overweight in the same month, both describing Bunnings and Kmart as high-quality businesses at a more attractive valuation.
30 managers, 58 comments, with each manager's latest recorded position.
See WES