Thesis Tracker

Contributors and detractors

What contributors and detractors are in a fund report, how contribution is worked out, and how to read what the manager did next.

Updated 18 Nov 2026 · 4 min read

In short

Contributors are the holdings that added most to a fund's return over the period and detractors the ones that cost most, sometimes measured against the benchmark. Contribution depends on both the price move and the size of the position. The most useful part is what the manager did next: added, held or sold, and why.

Open almost any Australian fund manager's monthly report and you will find a short section on the stocks that made the biggest difference to performance: the contributors and the detractors. It is often the most useful part of the report for anyone researching those companies.

What they are

A contributor is a holding that added most to the fund's return over the period. A detractor is one that cost the most. Some funds list them against the benchmark instead, so a contributor might be a stock the fund owned more of than the index while it rose, or a stock it avoided while it fell.

Contribution depends on two things: how much the stock moved, and how big the position was. A 30% rise in a 1% position adds about 0.3% to the fund. A 5% rise in an 8% position adds about 0.4%. So the biggest contributor is not always the stock that rose the most.

How to read them

Look for what the manager did next

The interesting part is rarely the price move, which you can see on any chart. It is the manager's response. After a detractor falls, did they add to it because the thesis is intact, hold and wait, or sell because something changed? After a contributor rises, did they take profits? That decision is what Thesis Tracker records as the position change.

Read the reason, not just the result

A detractor with a clear explanation ("the result missed on a one-off cost; we added") tells you more than a contributor with none. Managers often give their most detailed reasoning when defending a stock that has fallen.

Remember the period

A monthly report covers one month. A stock can be a detractor in March and a contributor in April. Read several months together, and compare them with what other managers wrote about the same company.

What contributors and detractors don't tell you

  • They only cover a few holdings. Most of the portfolio goes unmentioned.
  • They describe the past month, so any trades described may be weeks old by the time you read them.
  • Being named as a detractor isn't a negative view, and being a contributor isn't a positive one. Look for the position change.

On Thesis Tracker

When a manager discusses a company as a contributor or detractor, Thesis Tracker records the comment against that company with the reported position change and the share price on the day. A company page brings together every manager's comments, so you can see how several managers explained the same move. See How Australian fund managers report to investors and Reading a fund manager's position change.

Questions

What is a detractor in a fund report?

A holding that reduced the fund's return the most over the period, or, in some reports, the one that cost most against the benchmark.

Does a detractor mean the manager has sold?

No. Managers often hold or add to detractors when they think the fall is temporary. Look for the position change they report.

Related guides

General information only. Thesis Tracker is a database of what named fund managers have published about ASX companies. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and is not financial product advice or a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security.

13,085 comments from 169 managers on 783 companies, snapshot 16 Nov 2026.