Fund Manager Summary on Lifestyle Communities Ltd (ASX:LIC)
Lifestyle Communities Ltd (ASX:LIC) has faced significant challenges following an adverse ruling on its Deferred Management Fee structure, leading to substantial share price volatility. The market remains cautious as the appeal process may extend for up to 12 months, with potential write-downs impacting valuations. However, fund managers are maintaining a constructive outlook, highlighting structural tailwinds such as a recovering Victorian property market and demographic shifts favoring land lease communities. Progress in reducing net debt through land divestments and improved settlement rates underscores operational resilience. As the company continues to work through inventory and engage in strategic initiatives, the existing discount to net asset value presents opportunities for value recovery, though the ongoing appeal remains a pivotal risk affecting earnings and sentiment.
Commentary From The Managers
There are 13 insights from 5 fund managers regarding their investment in Lifestyle Communities Ltd (ASX:LIC) available on Thesis Tracker.
Unlock Updates With ThesisTracker Pro
Don’t let information asymmetry undermine your investment returns. Join other engaged investors on ThesisTracker Pro.
Updates are made available to members within 12 hours of being released. The completeness, accuracy or current status of the investments referenced are not guaranteed.
Commentary From The Managers
HMC Capital
30 Nov 2025
$5.67
Summary
- HMC Capital notes Lifestyle Communities (ASX: LIC) reported a steady start to FY26.
- Completed 93 settlements year-to-date, adding potential for 30 more settlements this fiscal year.
- Inventory continues to trend lower with 202 unsold homes as of Nov-25, down 14 from October.
- The completion of non-core land divestments has improved the net debt position to $338.3m, down from $460.5m.
- The update supports a continuing recovery post the unexpected VCAT decision.
- HMC Capital maintains a constructive outlook on the stock, which trades at a discount to NTA.
- Positive factors include an improving Victorian property market and ongoing VCAT appeal that may positively impact earnings and valuation.
HMC Capital
31 Oct 2025
$5.18
Summary
- HMC Capital notes a steady start to FY26 for Lifestyle Communities (ASX: LIC -9.8%), with 54 new settlements and 237 contracts on hand.
- Out of the contracts, 160 are due to settle this year, indicating strong operational performance despite external challenges.
- The number of completed homes awaiting sale has declined 16% to 216, showcasing effective inventory management.
- LIC has successfully completed several land divestments, notably in Ocean Grove, reducing net debt to $348m, ahead of target.
- The update is viewed as operationally sound and directionally positive, reinforcing a constructive outlook.
- There are signs of an improving Victorian property market, which is expected to enhance settlement momentum and balance sheet deleveraging.
- Broader demographic trends, particularly as baby boomers downsize, are anticipated to support growth.
- Despite recent underperformance in October on low trading volumes, HMC Capital remains optimistic about future prospects.
- LIC is currently trading at a ~14% discount to net asset value (excluding deferred tax liability), presenting a potential opportunity.
- The ongoing VCAT appeal outcome is identified as a key swing factor that could positively impact earnings and valuation.
HMC Capital
30 Sept 2025
$5.74
Summary
- Lifestyle Communities (LIC) underperformed this quarter, down -18% due to a negative outcome at the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT).
- In early September, LIC lodged an appeal with the Supreme Court of Victoria, with a decision expected in 6–12 months.
- Despite near-term challenges, HMC Capital remains constructive on the outlook, supported by:
- Supportive macro drivers from ageing downsizers and persistent housing undersupply.
- A clear plan to de-lever the balance sheet below $360m by December 2025, aided by $114m of contracted non-core land sales expected to settle over FY26, reducing equity raise risk.
- Signs of stabilisation in new home settlements, with 35 completed and 162 contracted in FY26, showing recovery from the FY25 trough.
- Optionality from a favourable outcome on the VCAT appeal, although uncertain.
- Valuation support as LIC trades at a discount to NAV/share (excluding deferred tax losses).
- Post quarter end, LIC provided a trading update indicating progress on de-gearing the balance sheet ahead of plan and stabilisation of sales and settlement rates.
- With a focus on delivery, a new marketing campaign, and supportive macro drivers, HMC Capital sees potential for the discount to narrow and will continue collaborating with management and the Board to drive value creation.
HMC Capital
31 Aug 2025
$5.48
Summary
- HMC Capital updates its investment thesis on Lifestyle Communities (+27.9%) following the release of FY25 results.
- Focus on steps taken to shore up the balance sheet and early sales and settlement rate trends in FY26.
- Clear path to de-lever the balance sheet by 31 December 2025, reducing equity raise risks.
- Signs of improvement in sales rates observed.
- Supportive macro thematics, including an aging downsizing population and housing shortage.
- Leverage to a recovering Victorian property market.
- Currently trading at a discount to NAV/share (excluding Deferred Tax Losses) despite DMF carrying value reduction.
- Uncertain but potential for a successful appeal of the VCAT decision.
- HMC Capital will continue to engage with management and the Board to drive value creation for shareholders and Fund investors.
HMC Capital
31 July 2025
$4.44
Summary
- HMC Capital notes that Lifestyle Communities (ASX:LIC) faced a significant decline of 37% this month due to an adverse ruling regarding its Deferred Management Fee (DMF) structure.
- The ruling from the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) was unexpected by the market.
- Lifestyle Communities plans to appeal the decision, which may take up to 12 months.
- If the appeal fails, the potential write-down impact on accrued DMF is approximately $1.44/share (post tax).
- The stock is currently perceived as oversold, trading near its adjusted NTA.
- In contrast, Ingenia Communities, a listed land lease peer, is trading at a premium of over 35% to NTA.
- Despite this setback, HMC Capital maintains strong conviction in the long-term fundamentals of the land lease sector.
- The sector benefits from real asset-backed exposure to residential trends, particularly with demand from downsizing baby boomers.
- HMC Capital continues to engage with LIC management to explore ways to recover value for shareholders.
HMC Capital
30 June 2025
$7.00
Summary
- Lifestyle Communities experienced a 10.0% decline in share price for the quarter.
- Recent update on VCAT proceedings regarding the Deferred Management Fee (DMF) structure indicates that hearings are concluded, with a decision expected by 6 July 2025.
- Post-announcement, the stock underperformed due to investor concerns about the resolution timeline.
- The recent IPO of Gemlife Communities may have impacted Lifestyle Communities as investors reallocated funds.
- Despite recent share price performance, HMC Capital maintains high conviction in the growth outlook for land lease communities in Australia.
- Expectations for a resolution on the DMF dispute, progress on non-core land sales, and stabilization in sales and settlement rates could lead to significant upside in share price.
Yarra Capital Management
30 Sept 2024
$8.43
Summary
- Lifestyle Communities (LIC) remains an overweight position for Yarra Capital Management.
- The company underperformed during the period due to a trading update.
- Lifestyle Communities withdrew its forward-looking guidance.
- The uncertainty was influenced by recent media coverage.
- Yarra Capital Management continues to monitor the situation closely.
Yarra Capital Management
31 July 2024
$9.00
Summary
- Lifestyle Communities Ltd (LIC) has underperformed recently due to a trading update.
- The company has withdrawn its forward-looking guidance.
- This decision is attributed to difficulties in quantifying the impact of uncertainty stemming from recent media coverage.
- Yarra Capital Management continues to monitor the situation closely.
- The fund manager's investment thesis remains under review in light of these developments.
Endeavor Asset Management
30 Apr 2024
$12.03
Summary
- Endeavor Asset Management sold their investment in Lifestyle Communities (LIC) due to concerns over extended ‘sales to settlements’ timeframes affecting the company’s balance sheet. <liInformation gathered through the network indicated little improvement in the sales dynamic, which raised doubts about the company's future growth.
- LIC's second half guidance for FY24 heavily relied on timely settlements, prompting Endeavor Asset Management to exit at an average price of $14.72/share.
- Post-exit, LIC announced lower settlement forecasts, leading to a share price drop to around $12/share, validating Endeavor Asset Management's decision.
- While optimistic about LIC’s long-term prospects and management quality, Endeavor Asset Management remains cautious due to short-term settlement and development cost challenges.
- The fund continues to monitor the share price for potential re-entry opportunities.
DS Capital
31 Mar 2024
$15.20
Summary
- Lifestyle Communities delivered a softer than expected earnings result due to slower new home settlements.
- The extending sales cycle resulted from higher interest rates and customer concerns about builder completion risk.
- Customers are waiting longer to put their homes on the market until they see a substantially completed home.
- Lifestyle announced a capital raising to leverage opportunities for adding sites that are typically unavailable in a robust environment.
- Despite recent developments, DS Capital remains confident in management's ability to navigate this challenging period.
Ausbil Investment Management
31 Mar 2024
$15.20
Summary
- Ausbil sold their investment in Lifestyle Communities (LIC) after a 12.9% decline in share value.
- A slower pace of new home settlements resulted in softer outcomes than anticipated.
- The announcement of an unexpected capital raising was disappointing to longstanding investors.
- The investment thesis for LIC was based on a capital recycling model, utilizing proceeds from house sales to fund future land purchases and developments.
- LIC's land lease model aimed to generate long-term recurring rental revenue.
- The decision to accelerate land purchases through capital raising is viewed as a breach of longstanding discipline.
- This shift may lead to heightened operational risks associated with increased development activity.
Ausbil Investment Management
28 Feb 2024
$14.97
Summary
- Ausbil noted a decline of -13.9% in Lifestyle Communities (LIC) shares.
- Slower new home settlements contributed to results that fell short of expectations.
- The announcement of an unexpected capital raising disappointed longstanding investors.
- LIC's investment premise is based on a capital recycling model that uses proceeds from house sales for future land acquisitions and developments.
- The company's decision to accelerate land purchases breached its longstanding discipline.
- This shift may introduce operational risks by increasing the pace of new development activity.
Endeavor Asset Management
28 Feb 2024
$14.97
Summary
- Endeavor Asset Management acknowledges a weak first-half result for Lifestyle Communities (LIC).
- The recent $275 million capital raise has led to some investor disappointment.
- Development expenditure has increased as anticipated, but delays in home settlements have negatively impacted the balance sheet.
- Management notes that cancellation rates remain low (less than 1% for deposits over $5,000).
- Settlements are expected to catch up in upcoming periods.
- The equity raise has overshadowed positive long-term growth prospects for LIC.
- Annuity cashflows from rental revenue and fees show strong growth, indicating future leverage from increased occupancy.
- The replenished balance sheet places LIC in a strong position to capitalize on discounted land being sold by financially troubled companies.
- This strategy should improve development margins over time due to lower land costs.
- Endeavor Asset Management continues to hold its existing LIC shares but did not participate in the capital raise.
The completeness, accuracy or current status of the investments referenced are not guaranteed.
Investment Ideas Scanner
Why fund managers back Summerset Group Holdings Ltd (ASX:SNZ): top-quality retirement play set to benefit from falling rates
Latest fund manager views on Siteminder (ASX:SDR)
Why fund managers backed QPM Energy’s Isaac Power Station milestone (ASX:QPM)
Airlie Funds (Aug 2025): Why Waypoint REIT (ASX:WPR) pays 6%+
Lendlease (ASX:LLC): $500m buyback via capital recycling — HMC sees re-rate
Why DMX invested in Careteq (ASX:CTQ): new CEO and FY25 profitability path
Harvey Norman (ASX:HVN): Fund managers spot hidden property-value upside
Why fund managers still back Credit Corp (ASX:CCP) — guidance intact, trading on 11x earnings
Fund managers exit AGL (ASX:AGL) over transition earnings risk
Dec 2024: Tyndall — Data#3 (ASX:DTL) can mitigate Microsoft pricing hit
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is investing in Lifestyle Communities Ltd (ASX:LIC)?
Fund managers including Endeavor Asset Management, Ausbil Investment Management, DS Capital, Yarra Capital Management and HMC Capital have invested in Lifestyle Communities Ltd (ASX:LIC).
Why do fund managers invest in Lifestyle Communities Ltd?
Fund managers invest in Lifestyle Communities Ltd due to its strategic position within the land lease sector, which is supported by demographic trends favoring downsizing baby boomers. Despite recent setbacks related to its Deferred Management Fee structure and a resultant dip in stock price, the company shows potential for recovery, with efforts to improve balance sheet stability and increasing sales rates. Additionally, Lifestyle Communities is trading at a discount to its net asset value, suggesting potential upside for investors, especially if ongoing challenges are resolved.
What happened to Lifestyle Communities Ltd (ASX:LIC)?
Fund managers maintain investments in Lifestyle Communities Ltd (LIC) due to a supportive macro environment driven by ageing downsizers and a persistent housing shortage. Recent operational updates indicate stabilizing home settlements and successful debt reduction, with net debt decreasing from $460m to $338.3m as of November 2025. Despite short-term challenges following a legal setback, LIC's discounted share price relative to net asset value suggests potential for recovery. The ongoing appeal against the VCAT decision is viewed as a key factor that could enhance earnings and valuation, along with anticipated improvements in the Victorian property market.
What is the short interest in Lifestyle Communities Ltd (ASX:LIC)?
The short interest in Lifestyle Communities Ltd (ASX:LIC) is 9.38% which makes it the 14th most shorted stock on the ASX. Of the 121.7M shares that Lifestyle Communities Ltd has on issue, 11.4M have been sold short.
What does Lifestyle Communities Ltd (ASX:LIC) do?
Lifestyle Communities Ltd. engages in the development, ownership, and management of land lease communities. It offers independent living residential land lease communities for senior citizens, as well as home designs, resort lifestyle homes with various sports and entertainment facilities. The company was founded by Dael S. Perlov, Bruce Carter, and James L. Kelly in 2003 and is headquartered in South Melbourne, Australia.